Saturday, September 21, 2024

LOTR

Of course, my LOTR title refers to Lord of the Rings. Along with The Hobbit, they performed an important function for me about more than 4 decades ago. Good grief! when I counted the years, I was almost shocked, but here we are, forty-plus years later, in my later seventies and not my earlyish thirties.

I was still a youngish teacher, but in my eleventh year I was transferred from my city high school to a country one. If that wasn't enough of a change, I was also tasked with doing some teaching out of my area. I was not in a happy place. Without droning on and on, let me tell you that my department head was arrested for attempted murder in the next year, and he had to serve time, so yes, it was a difficult transition in several ways.

Being shunted from a pleasant situation to what was then an unpleasant one for me, without a by-your-leave, was a tough experience, and I became depressed. I don't mean in a clinical sense, but my spirits were at a low ebb.

Before, I go on with the narrative, I am chiming in to tell you that it became a very good experience in the end. All told, I spent 12 years in that school in two stints of six years. I am thankful for the experience, but I had to get past that first year.

Somehow, I picked up The Hobbit, and being transported to a whole different world was wonderful for my mental health. I kept on reading the ensuing trilogy and loved it. The escape to Middle Earth was much of what I needed to cope with my work situation.

Twenty years later, LOTR was made into three movies. I was skeptical about them, wondering how it would be possible to adapt the series to the screen. Creating that world seemed like an impossible task, and we also know how films can take liberties with their source books.

I was completely impressed. To me, the films were about as faithful to the books as they could be, and they created Middle Earth and its characters better than my own imagination, or at least in a different and wonderful way. How they were able to create those characters and that world with the technology of that era  was both awesome and inspirational.

Twenty years later, Amazon has developed The Rings of Power, and I am somewhat on the fence. For sure they have created costumes and an environment that is really impressive, especially for a tv series. However, while the series definitely has been fashioned in the spirit of LOTR, it is a made-up story in a sense. The setting is eons before LOTR, and constructed from  bits of Tolkien's mentions in other tomes that he has written. They have added much to the bits and pieces while, in my view, maintaining the Tolkien authenticity, at least somewhat overseen by Tolkien's decedents. (At least this is the case as I understand it, but I am open to being corrected.)

I don't really mind that they have extrapolated and added material, for the series is very harmonious with the LOTR films in my unworthy opinion. I can tell you that the narrative does move slowly, and I wonder if those without a LOTR background would want to follow it. I even wonder about my own involvement sometimes, but I also know that I will see it through.

However, seeing it through, will take three more years, for they are only on season two of a projected five series.

I am interested to know if you are watching or will watch, and if you are a Middle Earther or not. If not but you are watching nevertheless, how does the series play for you, bearing in mind that season two isn't over yet?

23 comments:

  1. I haven't read the books. But I remember my brother being completed enthralled with The Hobbit when he read it as a teen. It's one of those books I know I will pick up someday and read, just because he loves it so much.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I have tried to read (and enjoy) TLOR and the various Tolkien works several times thinking I SHOULD enjoy them, but I never was able to feel “immersed” in the story (other than the pipe smoking aspects, which I did enjoy). I think they helped me realize I am not fond of “fantasy” literature where there is a complete defying of the laws of physics. I do greatly enjoy “traditional” sci-fi though….. but traditional sci-fi is usually couched in a speculative form of reality to a degree which grounds me or is more “psychological” which also is grounding and keeps me enthused. Purely “fantasy sci-fi” also leaves me cold, unfortunately. “Brave New World” is perhaps my favorite sci-fi book ever.

    PipeTobacco

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. There were several fantasy series that appealed back then but more recent ones have left me wanting.

      Delete
  3. I'm with PT. I really wanted to like LOTR more than I did. I tended to escape into mysteries and some YA fantasy novels when I needed the respite from the real world. I loved "Dune" which was also a world building tome.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I loved Dune as well. But the first movie did not impress me. If there is a second I haven’t seen it. Mind you I seem to recall older Dune movies.

      Delete
  4. I read The Hobbit decades ago. I probably still have. I don't remember much. I do almost no tv watching so I haven't seen it.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I loved The Hobbit all those years ago and never went further, but appreciate those who value this world of art and fantasy.
    "thankful for the experience, but I had to get past that first year."
    Life wisdom!

    ReplyDelete
  6. I read all of them and enjoyed the movies too. No interest in anything beyond that though. We limit TV watching to old movies and football (in season) and occasional MSNBC.

    ReplyDelete
  7. That is so shocking: "my department head was arrested for attempted murder" what happened?!

    ReplyDelete
  8. I read all the books and loved them. (My fantasy/sci-fi enjoyment includes many more things that Tolkien didn't get into!) I saw an early cartoon of The Hobbit in the 70s...I think it was animated. Then I loved Peter Jackson's directing of the three LOTR movies. The location was incredible. I haven't watched the TV series yet...finding the small screen just doesn't entice me as much somehow, but perhaps someday I'll start it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. PS, I've got the series on DVD of course.

      Delete
    2. We do as well. It’s been a few years since we pulled them out, probably during COVID.

      Delete
  9. I read The Hobbit and saw all the Lord of the Rings. I haven't seen The Rings of Power, but you've made me curious.

    I didn't read Harry Potter until one of my students gave it to me as a holiday gift. I then read the series. My 4th grade grandson has already read all of them and loved them so much, it replaced his Pokemon craze.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I read the Hobbit, once as a kid, and once as an adult, just to relive it. Perfection. I enjoyed the LOTR movies but did not read the books...some of my closest male friends absolutely love them. Not to be reductive, but over the years, I have noticed that The Hobbit & LOTR are great books to captivate reluctant male readers.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I've read the entire series, beginning to end, at least four times. Never saw the movies, though I understand they were excellent.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have even read them to Sue, I think more than once.

      Delete
  12. Dad brought us home The Hobbit and we fought each other for the book. We read all of the books. I read them at least 3 times. We were teenagers with vivid imaginations. We played in the summer running from the Ringwraiths, acting out different scenarios.
    My son, years later invited me to the first showing of the LOTR movies. We made it a date each year where I'd travel across the state to see it with him.

    As a kid, I read all of Edgar Rice Burroughs books and coveted the LOTR the most.
    Big Fan.
    I haven't started watching the Rings of Power yet. I enjoyed the first of the series and am holding off to start season 2 for some cooler weather.

    Big Big Fan of Fantasy. Though you may have guessed that.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I like how you and your son made it a special occasion. We also did it with family at least once and probably for all three.

      Delete
  13. The worst part of my teaching career was teaching outside of my area of expertise at the end of my career. Hateful experience, but no attempted murder that I know of.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Somehow, I escaped my childhood without reading LOTR or the Hobbit. I was long entrenched into my non-fiction only reading habit when someone finally convinced me to read them in my 30's. Like you, I really enjoyed them and was looking forward to when the movies were going to come out. But I absolutely hated the movies. They were so long and all the battle scenes seemed to drag on forever. I came out of those movies, forcing myself to watch all three, that I now have a bad taste in my mouth for the franchise and have no desire to watch the Rings of Power.

    ReplyDelete
  15. hahaha, in my neck of the woods, LOTR refers to Lake of Two Rivers, in Algonquin Park

    ReplyDelete
  16. Well, you had a baptism of fire!
    I'm not a great fan of mystical tales, though I did enjoy The Hobbit and had to adapt it for a junior school musical performance, which was great fun.
    I also taught a Tolkien, but never inquired if there was a relationship.
    I taught an Auden, too, and she was related to W.H.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Wow. Lots and lots of Tolkien fans. I read Hobbit as a child, I think, but I found TLOTR in my first year at university. Read Book I. Book III was available, but no Book II ever was reshelved. Some rotter kept it. I finally gave in and read III but I had to wait until I got home after exams to get II from our city library.
    I own the fancy version of the movie. But I am not following the latest attempt at Middle Earth as I cannot figure out half the time what they are trying to set up and it frustrates me.

    ReplyDelete